Think about a time when your place at work changed. Maybe you'd just started somewhere and were trying to work out how things were done, or you'd been there for years and your role was changing in a way that left you unsure where you fitted. You may have been coming back after an injury or time away, or finding out that your time with the organization was coming to an end. Was there someone who noticed how you were doing, and when you did tell them something, what happened afterwards?
You may remember someone who checked in again, explained something you hadn't understood, or helped change something that was making the situation harder. You may also remember being listened to quite kindly and then having much the same conversation a few weeks later, because nothing had happened. We may have worked hard to make it possible for people to speak, but we also need to consider what we do with what they tell us, and whether they ever hear back from us.
Organizations put an enormous amount of time and money into choosing people. We scout, draft, recruit, sign and hire. Once someone arrives, there can be an assumption that because we chose them, they're ready for everything that comes with being here, and we may not look closely again until there's a problem. I don't think that always comes from a lack of care. The organization is trying to get through a season while the athlete is trying to build a career, and those priorities don't always line up, so arrivals get rushed and departures can become something we deal with at the last minute.
What strikes me is how often we know that these moments are approaching. We know when a player is arriving and when a contract ends, and we often know well before the player does that their role is likely to change. That gives us an opportunity to prepare, even if we can't predict exactly how the person will respond. These are also the times when people are likely to be especially careful about what they say, because they're weighing whether asking for support will change anything, whether someone will think they can't cope, and whether it could affect their selection.
One way of thinking about what someone might need comes from Nancy Schlossberg's work on adult transitions, such as a new job, a divorce or retirement. Her framework uses four areas, often called the four S's: the situation (what's happening, how much choice the person had and what else is going on), the self (how they understand themselves and their experience of getting through difficult things), support (who is available and whether those people feel safe to approach) and strategies (the ways they have of coping). I find those useful as questions to explore with the person, because we shouldn't assume we can work it all out by watching.
When a new player arrives, they're learning how the team plays, but they're also learning how to be in the room: who explains something they don't understand, who seems irritated when they ask, and which questions they're expected to know the answers to already. Research on stress suggests that part of how people experience a demand depends on whether they believe they have the resources to meet it, and someone who feels out of their depth may become more concerned with protecting themselves and avoiding mistakes. So when a new player says, "I don't want to be a problem," I'd want to ask a little more. It may just be politeness, or it may mean they're worried that asking for something will change how people see them.
A clearer role, a named person to approach who isn't deciding whether they play, and more predictable feedback are things a club can organize before the player arrives. Check-ins at thirty, sixty and ninety days are one way of doing that. I'd want to know whether the player can describe their role for that week, who they would go to if something felt wrong, and what is happening in their life outside the sport, because if being an athlete accounts for almost all of someone's identity, an injury or a change in status can affect much more than their working day.
When a veteran's minutes are reduced, the coaches may see a necessary decision about the team, while the player is trying to understand their place in an organization where they've spent much of their career. Grief researchers describe a non-finite loss, one that keeps being encountered over time: when the team is announced, when someone else takes their place in a drill, or when a younger player becomes the person everyone looks to. If nobody talks about that, the player's response can be interpreted only as a behaviour problem. I'd want a private conversation about the role before the person has to guess what it will involve, and I'd ask them to describe the new role in their own words. If mentoring younger players is going to be part of it, the organization needs to recognize that work, make time for it and agree on what else comes off the person's plate.
An injury can change someone's routine, their contact with teammates and their sense of being useful to the group, sometimes very quickly. In 2003, Naomi Eisenberger and her colleagues had volunteers in a brain scanner play a simple computer game in which three players passed a ball to one another, and partway through, the other two stopped passing to them. The researchers reported activity in a brain region involved in the distress associated with physical pain, and that activity was related to how distressed people said they felt. This was a laboratory study, and we need to be careful about what we carry from it into a dressing room, but it gives us a reason to take the experience of being left out seriously, even when the people doing the excluding don't intend to cause harm.
Leslie Podlog and Robert Eklund spoke with athletes more than once as they returned from serious injuries, and their accounts included concerns about reinjury, pressure to get back and worries about their place in the team. So when an athlete says, "I'm not ready," I'd want us to take the information seriously and consider what it cost them to say it. Honest reporting of pain or difficulty shouldn't be punished, and safe participation still depends on medical fitness and psychological readiness, so we can protect someone's ability to speak honestly while being clear that we can't promise a particular selection outcome.
Leaving can change the daily structure, the relationships, the role and the future the person thought they were working toward, all at once. In my clinical work with people in this situation, what often stands out is disorientation: they're trying to work out when to get up, where to go, who they'll see and what to say when someone asks what they're doing. Many organizations I've worked with have had very little in place beyond a dinner, a gift or a phone number. Research on fairness at work and on transitions out of sport gives us reasons to tell people directly and privately, with the actual reasons, and to give them a say in how they say goodbye. One practical rule I recommend is contact within forty-eight hours of an exit decision from a named person who had no part in making that decision, with follow-up already arranged at two weeks and at four weeks. This is a follow-up arrangement, and anything urgent needs attention at the time.
Preparing for these moments gives us opportunities to listen, but we still have to decide what happens when someone tells us something. By the time an athlete tells someone they're struggling, they may have spent weeks working out who they can approach, how private information travels and what happened the last time someone asked for help. If they feel dismissed, if nothing happens, or if the information is passed to the coach without an explanation, they may become more guarded and keep the difficult part to themselves. The person hearing the concern doesn't need to diagnose it or know how to treat it. They need to acknowledge what they've been told, be honest about the limits of confidentiality and help the person reach the appropriate support, with that connection beginning the same day and urgent concerns acted on immediately.
Depending on your role, that might sound like: "Thank you for telling me. Let's get you in touch with our welfare lead today. They can explain what happens next and how your information is protected." The words need to fit the arrangements you actually have, and you shouldn't promise confidentiality you can't provide. The person coordinating support should have no role in selection and should explain the limits before asking someone to share more, because consent matters and safety concerns or reporting duties can require limited information to be shared.
I call the next part lane discipline: clear, written rules about who can see information and what they can use it for. A coach may need to know that a player needs a lighter week without needing the details of their treatment. Then people need to see that something happened, whether that means following up with the person who raised a private concern or telling the group what has changed after a broader issue. I worry that repeatedly asking people for their views and then doing nothing can teach them that speaking is pointless, and from the outside the issue may appear to have gone away when people have simply stopped expecting a response.
If you want to do something with this where you work, start with one person whose situation is changing now, then think about who else will be going through a change over the next ninety days: new arrivals, people whose contracts are ending, players whose minutes may drop and people in rehab. For each person, write down who is responsible for checking in and following up, and for the person you're most concerned about, work through the four S's. You can use green, amber and red as a simple way of organizing your concerns, as long as you remember that this is a conversation aid, not a validated assessment. And sometime this month, take an issue people have raised that can appropriately be discussed with the group and explain what you did about it.
I want to be clear about the limits of what I'm suggesting. Schlossberg's framework comes from counselling psychology, and the studies on exclusion were laboratory studies that don't tell us what any particular player is feeling. The check-ins, the use of the four S's to organize a conversation and the forty-eight-hour follow-up are practical approaches informed by research, and they haven't been validated as a package for sport. With teenagers, the power differences and safeguarding responsibilities need particular attention, and these suggestions have to sit within the safeguarding arrangements that apply to them.
I think many organizations have people who are listening carefully. What we need to examine is whether they can do anything with what they hear, and whether the people who speak up ever see a response. If you go back to the change in your own life that you thought about at the beginning, you may have a clearer sense of what helped, or what would have helped, and there may be one person who is still waiting to hear what happened after they spoke to you.
Prefer to listen? Listen to Episode 5 — 18 minutes ↗. You can also find it on Spotify ↗, Apple Podcasts ↗, Amazon Music ↗, Overcast ↗ and Pocket Casts ↗.
If someone you know works in sport and would find this useful, send it their way.
Catching up? Episode 1 ↗ explores the pressures people work under. Episode 2 ↗ asks whether it's safe to speak up. Episode 3 ↗ asks what makes a sport culture toxic. Episode 4 ↗ asks how teams make good decisions under pressure.
Free for subscribers: the Personal Playbook, a printable workbook to look back on your year and think through what you want from the next one. Get the Playbook ↗.
Dr. MCB
P.S. This series draws on the book Madeline Antony and I wrote, The Psychology of High-Performance Sports Organizations: Culture, Safety, and Leadership (Routledge). You can find the book here ↗.
